Conference realignment has been one of the most intriguing storylines of the last SEVERAL years, honestly. But during our 8 month hiatus, a lot of things happened. And happened QUICKLY.
The real reasons behind these conference moves are so deep and so multi-faceted that explaining all of them in a simple blog post would be near impossible. Tiered television rights, exit fees, litigation, stability (or lack thereof). Rivalries are ending and feelings are being hurt all over the place. Schools and conferences are also raking in STACKS of new paper, and looking to make inroads in unfamiliar and exciting places.
Someone’s gonna write a very interesting book about all of this once all the dominoes finally fall and the puzzle pieces fall into place.
But for now, let’s just catch up on what’s happened over the last year or so, shall we? (Seriously, I need to figure out where everyone is/will be for next season anyway. A little research won’t hurt!)
Anyway.
As I mentioned, conference realignment isn’t a new phenomena. The Big 12 knows this particularly well. Going into last football season, the Big 12 actually only had 10 schools. Colorado and Nebraska left the conference for the Pac-12 and Big Ten respectively, to help bring those conference memberships up to 12 (the Pac-12 also added Utah) so they could add a championship game.
Even after those monumental moves, there was a lot of tension in the air around a lot of programs. Many schools weren’t satisfied with their conference partners for one reason or another, and while some schools made surprise decisions to jump ship, others (ahem, MIZZOU) were more openly looking for suitors.
I think the best way to do this might be to go conference by conference for each of the power 6 conferences and discuss who’s coming, who’s going, and a little bit of the timeline and issues surrounding each move. Feel free to skip around and skim. I’ll probably repeat myself a few times.
ACC
Adding: Syracuse, Pittsburgh
Losing: Nothing
Back in September, the ACC made a huge splash by extending invitations to Syracuse and Pitt. Cuse and Pitt were once staple and flagship institutions of the Big East, and without them, the cupboards suddenly looked very bare for that conference, and loyalty was all but thrown to the wind.
When the move originally occurred, the ACC looked poised to make another move quickly. Rumors flew about Texas and Texas Tech joining the league, and UConn all but begged for membership.
Since picking up the Orange and the Panthers though, the ACC has been quiet on the realignment front. All that remains to be decided is when the schools will join the league and bring the ACC to 14 members.
The Big East bylaws indicate that in order to withdraw from the conference, schools must give 27 months notice and pay a $5 million exit fee. But, that may be up for debate. We’ll discuss that when we get to the Big East’s wrap up.
In my humble opinion, this move makes the ACC the best basketball conference in the land, hands down. Although we’ll all miss seeing the teams compete in the Big East tournament at the Garden, I get very excited thinking about regular season matchups that pit the Orange against the Tarheels or the Panthers against the Blue Devils. Doesn’t do much for me on the football front, but picking up key TV sets in Pennsylvania and New York obviously looks mighty attractive to the big wigs at the ACC.
Big 12
Adding: Texas Christian, West Virginia
Losing: Texas A&M, Missouri
Now THIS was and continues to be an emotional roller coaster for teams involved.
The catalyst for this was probably The Longhorn Network. Texas’ multi-million dollar network television deal with partner ESPN. Once it was announced, Big 12 teams were put on edge. The network means UT collects millions in third-tier television rights, monies that it doesn’t have to share with it’s conference partners. That could, of course, lead to a competitive disadvantage for schools that can’t support their own network.
I’ve really enjoyed hearing about the various failures of LHN since it’s inception. Whether it be from not being able to broadcast high school games, to not being able to find cable providers interested in carrying the Bevo-centric station, I’m personally quite pleased by all of it.
But 8 months ago, it made me and a lot of other Big 12 fans very, very uneasy. The mood was especially stormy in College Station, Texas. Stormy enough that the Aggies of Texas A&M announced they were ending their partnership with the Big 12 in the middle of the football season. In September, Texas A&M was named the thirteenth member of the SEC.
Around that same time, Missouri fans were flooding their administration’s inboxes with emails, launching social media campaigns (re: Mizzou2SEC.com ) and begging for a change. While it was pretty common knowledge that Mizzou saw itself as a member of the Big Ten if it wasn’t going to be a member of the Big 12, the SEC movement gained momentum FAST. People were freaking out about it. I know I was. I would be at work, entering live chats with reporters for the KC Star to get all the inside info I could. I basically became a daily visitor to newspaper websites from Texas, Oklahoma, and SEC country alike, trying to see what new things people had to say.
Anyway, by November, the move was complete, and Mizzou became the 14th member of the SEC.
Fallout was immediate. The Big 12 was suddenly down to eight teams. Conference commissioner Dan Beebe (definitely worth the fake account follow @danbeebe on Twitter, by the way) lost his job, and the Big 12 appeared on the verge of collapse.
But in came Chuck Neinas.
The interim commish swooped in and soon after he came, so did Texas Christian. The Horned Frogs jumped (heh, get it?) at the chance to join the Power Six conference they wanted to be in from the beginning–and quickly resolved things with the Big East. If you remember, TCU was originally targeted by the Big East for expansion. But they left that conference before they were officially a member, and just like that the Big East’s loss became the Big 12’s gain.
West Virginia’s road to the Big 12 was much messier. In fact, we’re not THAT late in reporting that the Mountaineers will play in the Big 12 in the 2012 season, after finally coming to terms on exit penalties with the Big East.
With TCU in the fold, Big 12 fans began discussing rumors about another expansion target. BYU, Louisville, West Virginia, Air Force and others were up for consideration. After a while, it appeared to be down to either Louisville or West Virginia. And finally, after what felt like a really long time–WVU was tapped as the Big 12’s newest member.
And then the hard part began.
I won’t go too much into it here, because honestly I don’t understand a lot of it. Basically, the Big East and West Virginia filed suits against each other in different states about adhering to Big East bylaws. Y’know. Those pesky things.
The Big East didn’t want to let WVU go–because obviously, they’re hurting for quality programs, especially in football. But finally, FINALLY, the issue was resolved. WVU is paying the Big East like, 9 million dollars, and the other 9 Big 12 teams are paying the Big East like, a million dollars each, and everyone is happy.
Isn’t that a neat little package? What a mess.
Big Ten
Adding: Nothing
Losing: Nothing
The Big Ten made a big deal of saying they were comfortable at 12 after adding Nebraska for the 2011 season.
During this latest round of realignment, a lot of folks were hypothesizing that the Big Ten might get in on the fun and make a splash, but it never happened. Personally, I’m not sure if it ever will.
The Big Ten won’t be influenced by whatever trends perpetuate throughout the college football landscape. And really, even when their chief rival, the SEC, does expand to 14–the Big Ten won’t feel the pressure to do the same.
The Big Ten DID manage to get some headlines by unveiling a new scheduling partnership with the Pac-12, but details on that are forthcoming. Hopefully that’ll be cool.
Big East
Adding: Temple (football 2012, all-sports 2013), Houston (all sports-2013), Southern Methodist (all sports-2013), Central Florida (all sports-2013), Memphis (all sports-2013), Boise State (football only-2013), San Diego State (football only-2013), Navy (football only-2015)
Losing: Syracuse (effective 2014 season), Pittsburgh (effective 2014 season), West Virginia (effective 2012 season), Texas Christian (effective 2012 season)
If you’re even reading this after looking at who the Big East is adding, I commend you and apologize for the headache. I mean, how confusing is this crap? It’s exhausting, but this is the reality of conference realignment.
Anyway, the Big East really had to scramble after losing two cornerstones of the conference–Syracuse and Pitt–to the ACC. That move majorly destabilized the conference, and what they’ve done since is do their best to counteract that effect.
If you talk on the record with anyone from the conference, I’m sure they’d TELL you that they’re confident in the moves the Big East has made. I’m sure they’d TELL you that they’re comfortable with their conference partners moving forward and excited to compete at a high level in the future. But when it happened, you bet your ass folks at UConn, Louisville, and Cincinnati were freaking the F*&K out. And they still might be, honestly. I mean, wouldn’t you be? The Big East was, and still is, frankly, in danger of losing it’s automatic qualifier BCS status.
ESPECIALLY since West Virginia is bolting, and TCU left the Big East at the altar. Both of those schools are now joining the Big 12. And looking at the dregs of what was once the Big East, do you blame them for jumping at the chance to get out?
Oh yeah. And there’s that issue about WVU somehow getting out of the 27 month notification period laid out by the Big East bylaws. West Virginia managed to get out for the 2012 season by throwing a huge amount of money at the Big East, assisted by their new conference compatriots. Dangerous precedent to set for the Big East, what with Syracuse and Pitt already betrothed to another conference, and others (*cough* Louisville *cough cough* UConn and Rutgers) probably catching the wandering eye.
I feel like I’m hating on the Big East. I probably am. But really, WVU football was about all there was out of the Big East for years. South Florida had a hot streak, too, I guess. And adding teams from Conference USA isn’t the best way to jump up your football competitiveness.
That said, adding Boise is huge. So they got that going for them.
But people who hate conference realignment base all their arguments on the Big East. And it’s hard to get over some of the issues that are bound to come up. Non-revenue sports from Houston and SMU also have new conference affiliation, after all. Think of the travel!!!
Anyway, I think it’ll be really interesting to see how long the Big East survives in it’s current form. I think it’s possible that it lasts a long, long time. I also think it’s possible that it fails in less than five years, and other conferences swoop in to pick up the schools that they deem worthy.
Interesting tidbit, Temple joined the Big East officially a day or two ago. It’s interesting because the Owls were kicked OUT of the Big East. Now that they’re desperate, they’re Big East worthy. Stupid Big East.
Pac-12
Adding: Nothing
Losing: Nothing
The Pac-12 was on the verge of ripping the Big 12 apart, and leaving Baylor, Kansas, Kansas State and Iowa State conference-less by picking up Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, Texas and Texas Tech to form the first 16-team superconference.
There was real fear in Big 12 country that that was going to happen. It almost seemed inevitable. And then, it didn’t happen.
Conference commish Larry Scott seemed really anxious to expand. But Pac-12 presidents didn’t share his desire. Can’t say I blame them. Oklahoma and Texas are great, great programs. And tough opponents. Though the forming of a Pac-16 superconference would likely strengthen the brand of the conference, it might have diminished the brands of individual schools in the western part of the country.
Anyway, no movement in the Pac-12 for this season. We’ll see how long that keeps up. I think Larry Scott wants to grow.
SEC
Adding: Texas A&M, Missouri
Losing: Nothing
The nation’s best athletic conference made a bold move and grew to 14 teams with the addition of the Aggies and Tigers.
The motivating factor for expansion was probably TV sets. Missouri and Texas have a lot of people in them, and make a new TV deal much more lucrative for the SEC’s television partners. An SEC Network similar to the Big Ten Network is on it’s way, very soon, and this move certainly makes that network more attractive to cable carriers. By expanding the footprint, the conference stands to collect millions more dollars off of it’s television contracts by restructuring them.
As far as athletics go, there are a lot of doubters and detractors from the SEC’s moves. Â A&M and Mizzou have had some success, but are they going to remain successful in the toughest football conference there is?
Issues remain with travel and scheduling. Teams want to retain traditional cross-division rivalries. Coaches don’t want to play 9 conference games. And as much as we all want it to make sense–Florida traveling to Columbia, Missouri for an eastern division game is probably a bit of a stretch.
But these partnerships last a long time. Nobody’s ever left the SEC. So all the doubters and detractors better get used to it–cuz like it or not, the Tigers and Aggies are your family now.
Posted in Sports
Tags: acc, Big 12, big east, Big Ten, Boise State Broncos, conference realignment, Houston Cougars, Memphis Tigers, Missouri Tigers, Navy Midshipmen, pac-12, Pittsburgh Panthers, San Diego State Aztecs, sec, SMU Mustangs, Syracuse Orange, TCU Horned Frogs, Temple Owls, Texas A&M Aggies, UCF Knights, West Virginia Mountaineers